I’m knitting a sweater for my son-in-law (Family Crew Neck) at his request. I was so very pleased to be asked. I have measurements and am ready to go. But this has turned out to be a challenge.
I’m trying out a new-to-me yarn and to be a good little knitter, I knit a swatch. I changed needle sizes twice and now have gauge. I even washed it. Pat on the back, I am being very, very good! I cast on.
Part way through I started to panic. It’s small. I did all the math again and then three more times and as far as I could tell the body is around 2″ smaller than it should be. I kept measuring it over and over, hoping it would be a little bigger each time. Ha, ha, I bet you’ve never done this.
Then the light bulb went on. I have a swatch. I find them somewhat unreliable at the best of times but this time I had one to blame. I measured my gauge on it and then on my sweater and … I had tightened up. This never happens to me. I am a really loose knitter. I was working with needles 2 sizes smaller than recommended to get gauge on my swatch and now I was telling myself that that was a mistake.
Hmmm, I washed my swatch just like I’m supposed to. Ah, ha. Another light bulb moment.
I dumped the whole sweater in the sink, needles attached and all, spun it out in my washing machine and laid it out (nice and neatly, not like this photo) and let it dry.

Voila, it relaxed and although it’s still 1/2″ smaller than I would like, it’s going to be fine. Phew.
I’m on the sleeves right now. I took out 1 round of knitting and started with new yarn. Here’s the difference in gauge. You can see that already the new section of the sleeve has a tighter gauge. I’m trying not to look at it.

I’m hoping to get this done this week. I don’t know if that’s possible but I’m giving it my best shot. Audio books, short walks and lots of knitting.
Cheers, Deb
Family Crew Neck raglan pullover
Glad the sizing worked out . I like the colours you/he has chosen .
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks. Tried it on my son-in-law and he likes it. Yay.
LikeLike
i love the colour blocking and the colours chosen. And for sure I can see the difference in the gauge. Scary for the knitter.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, scared me!! But happy after the wash.
LikeLike
Hi Deb,
Once again, Awesome Job and I love the color combo.
My knitting has been on hold for a few weeks while I am packing to move to Cobourg. And then I’ll need a couple of weeks to unpack & organize everything. Can’t wait to have needles in my hands again instead of a roll of tape.
Looking forward to pics of your finished sweater.
Peg B.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Good luck with your move. Hope you’re knitting again soon.
LikeLike
Gauge swatches lie, at least in my experience. So although I continue to do them when I’m making garments, I don’t really believe them. Which is why I usually start with the sleeves if I can, they tell me more about gauge, drape and fit than a swatch ever will. And even if my gauge is slightly off, the sleeves will usually be fine and I can then make any further adjustments before I knit the sweater body. And if the sleeve really isn’t working, there’s less to rip out than the sweater body 😉!
Your sweater looks great!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Good idea. Sleeves first would be a good swatch for sure.
LikeLike
Deb, I am the kind of person who wants specifics! LOL What kind of yarn are you using?
Glad it finally worked out, but I wonder about the yarn. Generally I prefer non-superwash wool, but my Florida-residing FIL asked for a machine-washable and-dryable “sleeveless pullover” (a vest), so I’m using 100% acrylic. The swatch washed nicely, but I still worry about it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m using Berroco Vintage DK. It 40/60 wool/acrylic so I was a bit worried too because I can’t block it bigger as if it was wool. It did relax once I washed it so I’m happy with that. It’s very soft and will be terrific over a short sleeved t-shirt.
LikeLike
Glad to hear it relaxed. I am currently knitting a little sweater and it is knitting up a bit smaller than I had hoped. Your experience gives me hope that it will relax a bit too and then it will be the perfect too big size I want for the growing darling it is for!
BTW, love the colour combo and hope you took some pictures so we can see it finished!
Heather
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m hoping for a relaxed sweater for you.
LikeLike